So Coleys is a pizza spot I wanted to try after antonios in pines closed We ordered two pizzas (margarita and a Chicago style with meats) along with two orders or garlic rolls. Let's start with the good, Chicago style deep dish pizza with meat. It was a damn good deep dish that was tasty and not greasy. I could eat this pizza all day. A few of these slices (it only comes in a medium pie) and ur good (at least I was as I was on my third Amber beer by the second piece.) Now the not so good- the margarita pizza verde a little sauce to add some taste to it. The bad- the young lady behind the counter took out our second helping of garlic tools from the oven and moved the rolls from the paddle (large spatchula that they pull the pizza from the oven with ) to the tim foil with her bare hands- after she just got done running the register and taking my money... Not good. Besides- the garlic rolls need a lot more garlic anyway as we still are the other batch- hope that wasn't the same and I didn't see those prepared... Let's hope. Lol I will still be on the hunt for the best pizzeria in south Florida- let the yelping continue!! If you know of the best pizzeria- please reach out to me! Thanks! Patrick
(3)
Joe E.
We love your pizza! The way you go light on the sauce, just perfect. Garlic rolls are super delish! Had friends over to watch the game, they were amazed & raving about how good it was. Coley's is my go to pizza place from now on. You're other food was really good as well. That philly cheese steak pizza roll, fuhgedaboutit!
(5)
Gilbert C.
The absolute best pizza in Broward. The crust is crisp, the ingredients are fresh, the varieties are plentiful. The BBQ Chicken pizza is a must have. BBQ sauce, chicken, bacon, onion rings, 2 cheeses. Also amazing as a roll. Only 4 tables inside so take it to go.
(5)
Nancy C.
There's nothing more satisfying than seeing a young and fresh group of people working in such an upbeat environment. Small and intimate this art enthusiast mastered the art of casual sit down eating. My husband and I ordered an XL Pepperoni pizza with a side of wings and garlic bread. WOW! I recommend this place to anyone that wants to enjoy great pizza and wings.
(5)
Erika H.
Coley's pizza is delicious! As close to NY pizza as I could find so far! Great job, Coley's. Keep it up.
(4)
Dustin M.
My family and I are new to the area and I think we just found our go-to pizza joint! I will give a detailed explanation of the positives, but first the only reason I give 4 stars is because the marinara sauce that came with the Stromboli was a little bland. I personally don't use sauce with my Stromboli so it hurts to give this place 4 stars when in reality they are 5 stars. But marinara flavor is a key part of a pizza place. Alright! My favorite part of the review which is explaining how awesome everything was only minutes ago. I love pizza. I love deep dish, NY style, hand tossed, home made, even Digiorno. If it's a well prepared pie, I will usually enjoy my experience. So this review is my whole family's experience because they are not nearly as forgiving as I am. We ordered an XL 1/2 cheese 1/2 pepperoni pizza and a pepperoni Stromboli. Both cooked to perfection. I have a daughter is incredibly picky and sometimes she'll shoot a pizza down if this over cooked. Not the case here. The Stromboli was so excellent and cheesy. Delicious. The only thing that I need to still judge is how the little bit we have left tastes after being in the fridge for a little bit. So other than the marinara sauce: 5 Stars. I called in my order to take home. Great phone experience. The girl who took my order was very kind and efficient. She was incredibly accurate with her time the meal would be ready to pick up as well. So I park my car and stroll into this place expecting to find either a large sweaty Italian man sweating over the toppings or a Mom and Pop working away to cook meals for the lovely residents of Pembroke Pines. Not the case. Instead I find a kitchen full of beautiful ladies, and a couple strapping young lads ENJOYING THEIR JOB! You don't see that very much and it was nice to see. Staff and customer service: 5 Stars. I thoroughly enjoyed my experience and I will most def be back. Eff it, I'm changing my review to 5 stars
(5)
Alex H.
I've seen a few dissatisfied reviews, but the two times I have been here I haven't had any issues. I usually have gone on Mondays when they have the 6 dollar medium cheese special, which is a good size for the price. Not to mention the service has always been good even when the place is packed. It's rather small, so take out and delivery is your best bet. Pizza isn't bad either, the cheese pizza is pretty good and has good flavor. My mom went to pick up a few days ago and I think an ordered got messed up half pepperoni half cheese. They gave her the pie and only charged her for cheese so she wouldn't have to wait. That's not bad when you think about it, again pizza wasn't bad. They're pretty good at handling the Monday crowds and the wait usually isn't too bad. While I can't give them 5 stars since there are a bit better pizza places in terms of flavor, this place isn't half bad. Good food, good prices, and good customer service. Maybe the bad reviews are due to bad customers but I've never had a problem.
(4)
Enid V.
Saturday night Pizza, wings and a little salad :) This is definitely my favorite! Cheese, crust and sauce are on point never over the top greasy or chain-restaurant tasting! Its pizza made with love!
(5)
Lauren S.
We ordered pizza and wings and Stromboli and everything was incredible. Tons of food. I was apprehensive to order a Stromboli for delivery, but It was incredible. Nom nom. We will definitely order this over chains in the future. I love supporting local businesses. Their Dali Lama and Lemon pepper wings are crave worthy.
(5)
Robertha P.
I ordered pickup and when I arrived to pick it up they had the box on top the oven. The pizza, wings and garlic bread was so hot and yummy. The garlic rolls were light and fluffy and tasty. The wings were Honey Garlic and Dali Mama wings were hot, crunchy and flavorful. The pizza had a nice thin crispy crust and lots of ingredients. The staff was so friendly as well. I ordered all this food and it was only $32. Great food, great price and open late. I'm definitely going back.
(5)
Mayra G.
I've been a customer here for a couple of years and Coley's is by far my favorite place for pizza. Crust is thin, crispy on the outside and soft of the inside. The lemon pepper wings are perfection. Prices are really good and service is amazing.
(5)
Francesca A.
Excellent pizza and garlic rolls, that says a lot for me since I'm not a pizza person at all. Definitely going to order again.
(4)
Nancy A.
I rarely write reviews by sitting in the restaurant cause i like to give them a chance to change the first impression, but this place started bad and has been getting badder by the minute. 1st its empty at lunch, never a good sign. The girl at the register was playing with her phone and actually told me to give her a mi the while she finish texting or doing whatever she was doing. Now I'm sitting waiting for my food and they are screaming in the kitchen, and not about food! I tried the cheese pizza and the garlic rolls, the latter were delicious. The cheese pizza was ok, nothing to rave about. The prices are pretty good. Would just recommend takeout or delivery
(3)
Ed R.
So far im very happy with this place. Probably one of the best pizza places in broward (second only to antonios pizza in east miramar). A good laid back place. I definately recomend this place to all the locals.
(5)
Jayme N.
Our family likes to buy pizza at least twice a month, and we are super pleased we tried Coley's Pizza. The pizza tasted great (not too much tomato sauce or too much cheese...just right) and my boys are super picky so this a plus. Service was great. The woman making the pizzas was all smiles in the front which makes the ambiance welcoming. Fun urban vibe and prices are reasonable too so we will definitely be back!
(4)
Terry L.
Now dizza izzza Pizza! WOW, I am a fan of this place, it's situated within a plaza on the west side of Pembroke Pines! Immediately upon entering this place, I got the vibe of fun and young (maybe it had something to do with the purple walls or the teenage mutant ninja turtle pictures on the ceiling). This place is rather small but they do have a couple of seats if you wish to sit and enjoy your meal. The food, the pizza was on point, it was hot and they were not cheap in using the toppings. It was not greasy and the dough was baked to perfection. The pizza had good flavor from top to bottom. The toppings I opted for were Pepperoni and Sausage with onions! The Wings were fantastic, they were fried, crispy and tossed into my selection of BBQ sauce. The sauce was extremely flavorful and a little spicy (just the way I like it). I also had the ZEPPOLES (which most places do not have), this desert is simple - dough that is fried and topped with powered sugar - but it is so addicting (like crack) as it's a little chewy and sweet. A great way to end a pizza meal! I did not expect much coming into this place but they have become my go to pizza place! If your in the area I would suggest stopping by and picking up a slice or an entire pie!
(4)
Kelsie C.
BEST pizza in south Florida! All their pizzas are GREAT and CREATIVE. Right now my favorite is the spinach Alfredo, but I go through stages. Everything is great and the people and atmosphere is unbeatable. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED
(5)
Allie B.
Great local pizza joint. We order from here exclusively. The hot wings are astounding. Whatever Nicole uses in the sauce is amazing. Mondays and Wednesdays are $6.00 cheese pizza days. The staff is always friendly and the atmosphere is cool and artsy.
(5)
Dee A.
Ordered 2 slices of cheese pizza and an order for 6 wings and they took 2 hours to deliver. REALLY?! Then when I called them the girl who answered the phone put me on hold rudely. And of course my pizza was freezing. NEVER EVER AGAIN!
(1)
Idy U.
OMG, I can't believe that I have been living by this gem for so many years. We ordered a simple pepperoni pizza. The crust, sauce, and toppings were yummy. The only setback was that the pizza was heavier on the oily side. I will be ordering pizza here from now on.
(4)
Eddie R.
so, I find this pizza place on yelp. Yelp has never let me down. So I decide to try it, and so should you. It is run by a bunch of really nice girls. The owner, a girl, makes her own sauce, dough, and various other stuff. I tried the pizza. Wow, pretty good. Thin crust, good sauce, good stuff. I've done this 3 times. Next time I asked, meatball or chicken Sangawich. She recommended the chicken. What a really good chicken parm sandwich. I went in today and thought I would try the meatball. Wow, also good. So, my recommendation is this, go/come here. Order something and prepare to enjoy the meal, atmosphere, cost, view (for guys and girls, you'll understand once you come here), Great place to bring the kids, family and friends. This might quickly become one of your favorite places to grab a bite. The door is always open with people coming in for pick up or to eat in. I highly recommend it.
(5)
Brian P.
Ordered a $6 pizza yesterday not expecting much and that's exactly what I got! Over cooked dry pizza. Learned my lesson.
(1)
Jorge G.
Coleys is the best pizza in Pembroke Pines. Let's start with there service, always friendly and there delivery is exceptionally fast. They will tell you fifty minutes and it will arrive in thirty!! The pizza here is NY style and delicious, sure it's a little greasy but who doesn't like greasy pizza? Great job coleys keep it up.
(5)
A C.
This is not the only pizza place in W. Pines. I think she's the owner, she stood the and could not be bothered to greet her customers. Wearing a tank top. Then I ordered my pizza. Said I would be right back. Then I sent my son in they said a few more minutes. So we were right outside waiting, but even though the pizza was ready no one could be bothered to bring it out to us. And I heard them talking about ways to bring in new customers....well try treating the ones in front of you with some customer service!!!!
(1)
Santy A.
I tried out Coley's Pizza a few weeks ago with the kids. We had pizza and the honey BBQ wings mixed with the mild sauce. It was delicious! The kids won't eat pizza from anywhere else now and I'm addicted to the wings. We loved the food so much we decided to give them a try for my birthday party. All I can hear at my party was, "where did you get the wings from? Where did you get the chicken parm. from?". Needless to say the food at my party was a huge success thanks to Coley. We had baked ziti, chicken parm. 200 chicken wings honey garlic and honey BBQ, and their awesome garlic bread. If you are looking for great flavor and a hip place to get food from, and good customer service, I suggest you try Coleys Pizza.
(5)
Justin G.
My God! How did I not find this place sooner?! By far the best pizza I've had in a very long time. Could arguably be the best pizza secret in S. Florida. Delivery is a little slow (greater than 30 minutes), but it's more than worth the wait! Run. Don't walk.
(5)
Fred N.
Follow up on my recent visit, I had placed an order for a pick up at 8:30. I got an automated call minutes later to let me know that the order will be ready in 30 minutes. When I got there a little pass 9pm, I went to the counter to pay for my order. Few minutes later, the cashier told me that my pizza was ready but the wings are not but they should be ready soon. Okay, no problem, I can wait. Maybe I'm too patient but I waited 20 minutes. 20 minutes for just 6 wings?? Okay, let me ask to see where's my order. One of the girls said, oh your order is not yet ready. The wings are ready but the pizza's in the oven now. WTF?!? I thought I was just waiting for the wings?! Apparently, my pizza was probably given away to another order so now I have to wait for ANOTHER 10 minutes for the pizza. This is ridiculous. There was people that came in later than me and they already got their order and left. Smh...there's some serious issues here with how they manage orders. They are lost when it comes to order priorities because they have so many people in the kitchen and cashier. I shouldn't have waited for 30+ minutes considering that I placed the order online for a pick up. I'm not sure if I'll be coming back. I'm a frequent customer and I'm genuinely disappointed.
(1)
Jonathan D.
Best Ninja Turtle pizza in town! Came here as a bday surprise and loved it. Friendly staff, fun environment (board game play and cool paintings throughout the ceiling tiles), and the pizza was delish of course! The place is small, more for grab-n-go, but there are some tables to sit in and eat.
(5)
Sylvia F.
My son loves this place. We usually order the pizza and wings. My son is very picky so when I find a place he likes......then I like. Staff and owner are very friendly. On week days they have great specials. I always order for pick up. Every time order has been ready when I arrived. The place has a great vibe to it and is clean. Love the fact that the owner is right in front preparing every pizza.
(4)
Sara M.
In preparation for the new year, and new year's resolutions, aka: diets, I tried hard to get in all the carbs and calories that I could before setting off on the journey of bland and lifeless cuisine for however long I can stand it. Enter in Coley's for a family pizza night. As I have said before, I do not have an affiliation to any one pizza place and basically go where ever the wind takes me.. or where we have a coupon for. Coley's Pizza had a great deal going on, so naturally they beat out all the many competitors. The deal was for two medium, one-topping pizzas and 6 garlic roles for $20. Actually the coupon we had was expired by 10 days but when we called up and asked if they would honor it, they said sure, no problem. I for one was pretty shocked by this, I am just used to companies being sticklers with their coupons and deals, so Coley's definitely won over some points with this. On top of honoring the expired coupon, they even took off the difference of a topping when we ordered one of the pizzas as just cheese. Who does that? That's awesome! I really appreciate a business that is run with the customer in mind. Great job Coley's! Now on to the food. The pizza was good, it wasn't great, but good. It just missed some pizzaz or that punch of flavor. However, it was not greasy or burnt and the crust was nice. The garlic roles were pretty delicous though. They were really chewy and fluffy and had good garlic flavor without being too overpowering. I would say that their pizza is not my favorite in the area, but definitely a good option. Also, the store was clean and they had an open kitchen so you can see the pizzas being prepared right in front of you, which I always like.
(3)
Daddi L.
Amazing Food ! The prices are incredible ! The customer service is awesome ! The pizza is epic perfect blend of cheese with tomato sauce the dough is baked to perfection just enough to satisfy the Saturday afternoon need for good food
(5)
Alex P.
I still love this place!!!! They have a BBQ pizza that is to die for. This is my go-to place in Pines for pizza!
(5)
Raymond Z.
I came here around 10:30 after a local concert. They closed at 11 but were still happy and willing to seat a friend and I to dine in. For $9, we split a Medium cheese pizza (14" cut into 8 slices). Aside from wishing there was a little more sauce, I have no complaints. Great spot if you're in the area and you'll get good quality for less cost!
(3)
Cristina W.
This is the best pizza in south FL!! Everything is fresh and warm, wings are phenomenal and the service can't be beat. I love their cheese pizza, reminds me of how real NY pizza tastes like. Their blue cheese for their wings is also awesome and has actual chunks of blue cheese.
(5)
Joseph B.
Coley's is the best NYC style pizza in Pembroke Pines. The pizza is very good. Almost as good as my grandmother's, who is from Italy. I have been coming here for over a year and never received bad service. Nicole the owner is always very friendly and her staff is great. Recommend it highly, if you like New York style pizza.
(5)
Erik P.
Amazing Place. Best Pizza. Best Wings. Great atmosphere, cool staff! Coley is always in there working her butt off with a smile on her face. Support her small business! Definitely made a regular out of me. She even knows my voice when I call - and exactly what I'm going to order. Monday is 6$ medium pizza deal (still big!) and Tuesday there are wing deals! Saturdays sometimes they have kid pizza making class for $5.
(5)
Max B.
Coley's is our go to for pizza. I know they have plenty of items on the menu and everytime I order I tell myself next time i will try something from the menu. The problem is the pizza is so good I cant think of ordering anything else. I have ordered the wings, they are good but still cant beat the pizza. Good service, they are fast, and always get my order right. What more can you ask for.
(4)
Nikki C.
Coleys Pizza is by far the best ever! It's comparable to the great pizza spots I been to in NYC. Take out is very quick. I order delivery and it's here so fast! I met coley once and she is very nice, along with the rest of the staff.
(5)
Andres O.
The pizza was okay. Very greasy and no napkins to be found anywhere. The service was mediocre and the place was pretty tight in space. It made it kind of uncomfortable. I won't be going back soon especially since pizza places are abundant in this part of Pembroke Pines
(3)
Michelle G.
Coley's is the best pizza joint on this side of town. The garlic bread points are god send (much better than the rolls) and the pies are 100% wow! Love the powdered zeppoli with condensed milk dipper! Way to go, Coley's -- you never let us down!
(4)
Jenny Q. V.
Uh... I've had better. Prices are pretty good but food is BLAH. I ordered barbq wings and they were pretty boring and tasteless. Ordered the spaghetti and meatballs and got spaghetti and meat sauce more sauce then meat. It's close to home but I will probably never order from there again. I rather go to doughboys right across from Flannigans on pines blvd
(2)
Luis L.
Great place for pizza. All the varieties of pies i have had are good. I recommend to all. Plus, service is always great and friendly.
(4)
Ronald S.
The best pizza in Pembroke Pines West. If you go there and order your pizza will take a some good minutes but it is a good opportunity to see that everything are carefully made and fresh.
(5)
Elizabeth A.
Love the way they make the pizza, wings and the service is excellent. I recommend this place to anyone!!!
(5)
Milden D.
They are the best pizza in Pembroke Pines hand off! A relocated NY native I know my pizzas and this the closest to NY style pizza I've had. Their wings and homemade sauce yum! Also tried their signature wing it pizza and it was amazing (you can choose the wing sauce)
(5)
Arlette S.
Really good pizza was our first time to this place and will go back again I love the pizza I ate 4 slices I had to stop myself because I was about to eat the entire pie That's how good the pizza was !!!!good job guys !!!
(5)
Dee D.
I ordered delivery, online, at 1:15pm. I received a call from an automated system saying it would be 45 minutes plus delivery time. At 2:30 I called and the woman on the phone was very dismissive and told me the driver left over 15 minutes ago. The driver arrived shortly thereafter. Dropped off our appetizers (wings and an appetizer sampler) and tells us he grabbed the wrong pizzas and would be right back with the correct order. We were grateful he left something. I open the appetizer platter and realize they did not provide my onion rings that I ordered. I called back and the same woman wouldn't let me get a word in, and just went on to explain that the food should be there any minute. I waited for her to stop talking then explained the reason for my call. She then says "well since he has to go back I will send onion rings", so if not you wouldn't have sent them? No apology or anything for the mistakes. The driver arrived at around 3:15 with our new pizza and onion rings. The pizza was warm at best, borderline cold. He did apologize for all the confusion, though there was no attempt at customer service recovery. I expected a bit more after waiting for 2 hours for pizza.
(2)
Aramis F.
We ordered pizza from here for the first time, we ordered this thing that comes with a small container of condensed milk it's like a dessert. The guy who packed the pizza put the condensed milk container in the pizza box, needless to say it melted and spread the condensed milk under the pizza. We called and they said that they would send another pizza which they did but they wanted the messed up pizza back when they guy arrived he said we Should not have eaten any of the pizza which we had a few slices that where not damaged. The way this restaurant handled this sucked. I would have let the customer keep the messed up pizza due to the inconvenience so that at least they could have a few slices while the problem is corrected. I will definitely not order from there again. It was our first time and now it will be the last. You want better pizza try Marcos pizza, at least I have never had any issues like this. What crap Customer service and the pizza is not all that.
(1)
Yes B.
This had been our go to pizza place. Staff is super friendly, the wings are awesome and the pizza is always a hit at our house. They offered a pizza making class a while back and we had our boys (7 and 9) make pizza with Nicole. They had a blast! Lately the pizza has not been as good as it used to so Im giving it 3stars.
(3)
Nicole C.
Delicious food! Easily the best pizza in Pembroke Pines. The environment is fun and enjoyable and the service is always great. Last night we actually decided to try something other than our regular half cheese/half pepperoni and had buffalo chicken Philly cheesesteaks. Yum. They were to die for. I definitely recommend that to anyone who isn't in the mood for pizza.
(5)
Bardiya A.
One of the best pizza that I have eaten in the U.S. I liked the NY pizza with my topping selection which was black olives, sausage, pepperoni, and onion. The smokehouse pizza was kind of sweet, but It was delicious. I picked up the pizzas, so I didn't have any problem with delivery stuffs. The price was good. The problems are that they did not have enough seats, and the staffs were not very friendly. I have to mention it again, I really liked the pizza taste.
(4)
A M.
So, I just moved to Florida and I am looking for a good pizza place. The reviews made this place sound like the most amazing pizza ever. Ok, so maybe I ordered on a off night. I ordered The Smokehouse pizza, a pepperoni stromboli, chicken wings and their zeppoli donuts. All of the dough was chewy, like really chewy. Not sure if it was old dough or what. The chicken wings half honey garlic / dali lama, they were fresh but had no flavor, we had to put BBQ sauce on them. The stromboli was OK, still chewy. The zeppoli donuts were chewy as well.The food was edible because I was hungry. Not sure if I will give this place another shot. This was literally the chewiest pizza I have ever eaten. Not cool
(2)
Selene T.
This place is great. The food is fresh and awesome! The owner, Nicole, is very nice and she makes everything in-house. She'll be tossing pizzas and talking to you at the same time. We have eaten here 3 times, once on a a week night, once on a weekend night and the third time on a weekday afternoon. They are always busy! A sign of good food. We've had the subs.... The eggplant parm ($6) 8"sub was amazing, the bread is nice and warm, soft on the inside and toasty on the outside. My husband had the philly cheesesteak ($7.50) and they use great tasting meat, lots of onions, peppers, and cheese. Now for the bonus, they have Curly Fries (only $1 more added as a side for the subs)!!! we always order a side of their homemade medium wing sauce. We like spicy food, but the medium here is the Hot anywhere else. So be careful. The pizza dough is amazing, the sauce is so yummy, it has Parmesan cheese in it. Now to the mozzarella.... Good and fresh cheese will stretch and it will not be chewy, here Coley's hits a home run, so flavorful. We had The Edgy Veggie pie ($15 for the 14") and it had tons of Fresh vegetables, and this pizza looked way bigger than 14 inches. (I put a photo up, check it out) Today we tried their pasta. The spaghetti and tomato sauce ($7). All their pasta dishes come with 2 amazingly airy garlic rolls and a side salad. What a great deal. I took 1 star off because each time we've come the tables have been dirty, they need to pay more attention to that. They do come and clean them when you ask :) And because the pasta was a little over cooked (in my opinion) and the sauce was lacking flavor. We had to add lots of pepper flakes, salt, garlic, oregano and Parmesan cheese to make it taste better. We did tell Nicole about it and she said that she'll be happy to add more flavor to ours if we remind her when we're ordering :) NOW THAT'S SERVICE!!! Check out their menu, I put pictures up.
(4)
Jay F.
Coley rocks! She makes the best pizza in town. Affordable and really customer service oriented.
(5)
Sharyna B.
Amazing pizza place. Me and my guys order from here all the time at work. A+ just wish they gave us a military discount. Lol.
(5)
Veljne A.
This place will redefine your love for pizza. You'll never order a pie from another place once you've had a slice at this neighborhood friendly joint. Stop on in and pick up a pie, a Coley's T-shirt, and some stickers while you're at it.
(5)
Suhay R.
I love coming here to get pizza. The staff is friendly and prompt. I have never had any issues here. The manager and staff are ALWAYS ready to assist.
(4)
Raquel E.
Best pizza in West Pines!!! Great service and the pizza is so yummy. It's not all crust and bread, it's actually thin delicious pizza.
(5)
Mary Ann C.
We ordered a few pizzas to go from here and were happy with the results. I've heard that they have the recipe from Baci's Pizza which is now gone. They don't have a brick oven but their pizza is nice and crispy with lots of cheese. It was a hit with the kids, especially the extra large size the offer. They have pizza specials on Tuesdays. The staff were very friendly and helpful in ordering and picking up. Now I'm getting hungry. This week I'm ordering Coley's!
(4)
Shanna L.
Great NY style pizza! The hot wings are crispy and the sauce is not just your typical sauce, it's flavorful and delicious. We have had the food delivered and have often picked it up ourselves and the food has always been hot and our orders have been correct. Love supporting small business rather than a chain and trust me, This place is definitely worth it!
(5)
Karen C.
Don't know what happened here, whether it was bad night or what cause there are some good reviews but we got delivery a few of nights ago and will never order from them again. Pizza soggy and greasy. Margherita pizza had a funny "off" taste to it that got even worse with leftovers next day. We ended up throwing away all but 2-1/4 slices of Margherita, over half of the meatball pizza and a couple of slices of the pepperoni. I will say food was delivered well before promised time (and that's the only reason they got 2 stars) and that was a plus but can't afford to waste money by throwing food away.
(2)
Bryan K.
This place is a nice local pizza dive place...typical New York dirty style restaurant. Front door is always open I guess they have no clue it's a health code violation..If you watch no one ever washes there hands even after touching money ...then they cut a pizza and touch it to make it fit in boxes that they only make when the pizza comes out... ..There is always a wait on Friday and Saturday and everyone seems to run around like a chicken with there head cut off..last time we got a salad there we had hair as a topping in it... But with that said it is probably the best pizza west of 75..
(3)
Timothy M.
My go to pizza joint. So much better than the chains. The only pizza I'd rather have is up at home in Chicago. I've recommended Coley's to friends and they all love the place.
(5)
Charles G.
Just ordered 2 pizzas with garlic rolls for delivery. Reasonable delivery time and the pizzas were delicious. Found a new pizza place. No more Pizza Hut or papa johns. Love fresh made crust.
(5)
Nikki C.
I recently relocated back to Pembroke pines and was in search of a good pizza place. So I sent my hubby to do some research and he came across Coleys pizza so we decided to give Coleys a try , I must say I am so happy we did :) The food is very good The pizza was delicious as well as the wings & fries. You should definitely give them a try !!! You wont be disappointed!
Takes Reservations : No Delivery : Yes Take-out : Yes Accepts Credit Cards : Yes Good For : Lunch Parking : Private Lot Bike Parking : Yes Wheelchair Accessible : Yes Good for Kids : Yes Good for Groups : No Attire : Casual Ambience : Casual Noise Level : Average Alcohol : No Outdoor Seating : No Wi-Fi : Free Has TV : Yes Dogs Allowed : No Waiter Service : No Caters : Yes
Pizza is a famous Italian dish savored around the world. The entire credit for the popularity of Pizza in the United States goes to the chain of pizzerias all over the country. While the base and the texture of Pizza remains same across the globe, it's the toppings that differs from country to country. In the United States, you will find the top pizzerias serving pizzas with the toppings of mainly beef, bacon, chicken, ham, and sausage for the non-vegetarians. Other than these famous meat options, Pizzas with veg toppings such as mushrooms, pepperonis, garlic, tomatoes, spinach, etc. are also famous in most restaurants in the United States.
Irrespective of your locality, you will find a variety of different restaurants in your cities offering pizzas of all different types. Pizza is hot favorite among people of all ages in the United States. A large size pizza is enough to feed a family of 3 or 4 at large. Pizza is also the most preferred food whenever a group of friends is hanging out together. Pizza gained popularity in the United States after the American soldiers stationed in Italy returned from World War II.
Over the years, different pizzerias in the United States have developed their own respective regional variations. Pizza gained popularity as the iconic dish in the United States in the second half of the 20th century. Whether you prefer thin or thick crust pizza, you can find a pizza of your preference at the best pizza restaurants in your city.
Italian Cuisine
The immense popularity of Italian cuisine globally isn't unknown. You can find an Italian Pizzeria around every corner of almost every city in the United States. Not to forget that in every house, people enjoy mac and cheese as comfort food. But it would be wrong to believe that Italian food starts with pizza and ends with good pasta as this Mediterranean country has much more to offer other than these two dishes. In Italian Cuisine, there is a high use of fresh tomatoes, all kinds of herbs, great quality of cheese, all types of meat, seafood and fresh handmade pasta. Many find it hard to believe that Italians have been making noodles long back.
Italian and Greek cuisines are always mistaken to be same, but they are poles apart. The primary difference between the two cuisines is the use of cheese in most of the Italian dishes. Italians love to cultivate their own cheese and process them as per their food requirement. It is believed that some cheese is so expensive that cheese producers secure them in lockers.
If you are bored eating the same old pasta or pizza, you can try some of the authentic Italian dishes like Risotto, Polenta, Ribollita, Lasagna, Fiorentina Steak, Bottarga, Ossobuco, Carbonara, Focaccia, Arancini and Supplì. Another item which Italians love to relish every morning is a good cup of Italian Coffee. Once you taste a freshly brewed cup of Italian Coffee, you might not visit Starbucks ever again. Authentic Italian food is made with heart and soul, so go find a restaurant where you can relish Italian cuisine in your city.
Patrick P.
So Coleys is a pizza spot I wanted to try after antonios in pines closed We ordered two pizzas (margarita and a Chicago style with meats) along with two orders or garlic rolls. Let's start with the good, Chicago style deep dish pizza with meat. It was a damn good deep dish that was tasty and not greasy. I could eat this pizza all day. A few of these slices (it only comes in a medium pie) and ur good (at least I was as I was on my third Amber beer by the second piece.) Now the not so good- the margarita pizza verde a little sauce to add some taste to it. The bad- the young lady behind the counter took out our second helping of garlic tools from the oven and moved the rolls from the paddle (large spatchula that they pull the pizza from the oven with ) to the tim foil with her bare hands- after she just got done running the register and taking my money... Not good. Besides- the garlic rolls need a lot more garlic anyway as we still are the other batch- hope that wasn't the same and I didn't see those prepared... Let's hope. Lol I will still be on the hunt for the best pizzeria in south Florida- let the yelping continue!! If you know of the best pizzeria- please reach out to me! Thanks! Patrick
(3)Joe E.
We love your pizza! The way you go light on the sauce, just perfect. Garlic rolls are super delish! Had friends over to watch the game, they were amazed & raving about how good it was. Coley's is my go to pizza place from now on. You're other food was really good as well. That philly cheese steak pizza roll, fuhgedaboutit!
(5)Gilbert C.
The absolute best pizza in Broward. The crust is crisp, the ingredients are fresh, the varieties are plentiful. The BBQ Chicken pizza is a must have. BBQ sauce, chicken, bacon, onion rings, 2 cheeses. Also amazing as a roll. Only 4 tables inside so take it to go.
(5)Nancy C.
There's nothing more satisfying than seeing a young and fresh group of people working in such an upbeat environment. Small and intimate this art enthusiast mastered the art of casual sit down eating. My husband and I ordered an XL Pepperoni pizza with a side of wings and garlic bread. WOW! I recommend this place to anyone that wants to enjoy great pizza and wings.
(5)Erika H.
Coley's pizza is delicious! As close to NY pizza as I could find so far! Great job, Coley's. Keep it up.
(4)Dustin M.
My family and I are new to the area and I think we just found our go-to pizza joint! I will give a detailed explanation of the positives, but first the only reason I give 4 stars is because the marinara sauce that came with the Stromboli was a little bland. I personally don't use sauce with my Stromboli so it hurts to give this place 4 stars when in reality they are 5 stars. But marinara flavor is a key part of a pizza place. Alright! My favorite part of the review which is explaining how awesome everything was only minutes ago. I love pizza. I love deep dish, NY style, hand tossed, home made, even Digiorno. If it's a well prepared pie, I will usually enjoy my experience. So this review is my whole family's experience because they are not nearly as forgiving as I am. We ordered an XL 1/2 cheese 1/2 pepperoni pizza and a pepperoni Stromboli. Both cooked to perfection. I have a daughter is incredibly picky and sometimes she'll shoot a pizza down if this over cooked. Not the case here. The Stromboli was so excellent and cheesy. Delicious. The only thing that I need to still judge is how the little bit we have left tastes after being in the fridge for a little bit. So other than the marinara sauce: 5 Stars. I called in my order to take home. Great phone experience. The girl who took my order was very kind and efficient. She was incredibly accurate with her time the meal would be ready to pick up as well. So I park my car and stroll into this place expecting to find either a large sweaty Italian man sweating over the toppings or a Mom and Pop working away to cook meals for the lovely residents of Pembroke Pines. Not the case. Instead I find a kitchen full of beautiful ladies, and a couple strapping young lads ENJOYING THEIR JOB! You don't see that very much and it was nice to see. Staff and customer service: 5 Stars. I thoroughly enjoyed my experience and I will most def be back. Eff it, I'm changing my review to 5 stars
(5)Alex H.
I've seen a few dissatisfied reviews, but the two times I have been here I haven't had any issues. I usually have gone on Mondays when they have the 6 dollar medium cheese special, which is a good size for the price. Not to mention the service has always been good even when the place is packed. It's rather small, so take out and delivery is your best bet. Pizza isn't bad either, the cheese pizza is pretty good and has good flavor. My mom went to pick up a few days ago and I think an ordered got messed up half pepperoni half cheese. They gave her the pie and only charged her for cheese so she wouldn't have to wait. That's not bad when you think about it, again pizza wasn't bad. They're pretty good at handling the Monday crowds and the wait usually isn't too bad. While I can't give them 5 stars since there are a bit better pizza places in terms of flavor, this place isn't half bad. Good food, good prices, and good customer service. Maybe the bad reviews are due to bad customers but I've never had a problem.
(4)Enid V.
Saturday night Pizza, wings and a little salad :) This is definitely my favorite! Cheese, crust and sauce are on point never over the top greasy or chain-restaurant tasting! Its pizza made with love!
(5)Lauren S.
We ordered pizza and wings and Stromboli and everything was incredible. Tons of food. I was apprehensive to order a Stromboli for delivery, but It was incredible. Nom nom. We will definitely order this over chains in the future. I love supporting local businesses. Their Dali Lama and Lemon pepper wings are crave worthy.
(5)Robertha P.
I ordered pickup and when I arrived to pick it up they had the box on top the oven. The pizza, wings and garlic bread was so hot and yummy. The garlic rolls were light and fluffy and tasty. The wings were Honey Garlic and Dali Mama wings were hot, crunchy and flavorful. The pizza had a nice thin crispy crust and lots of ingredients. The staff was so friendly as well. I ordered all this food and it was only $32. Great food, great price and open late. I'm definitely going back.
(5)Mayra G.
I've been a customer here for a couple of years and Coley's is by far my favorite place for pizza. Crust is thin, crispy on the outside and soft of the inside. The lemon pepper wings are perfection. Prices are really good and service is amazing.
(5)Francesca A.
Excellent pizza and garlic rolls, that says a lot for me since I'm not a pizza person at all. Definitely going to order again.
(4)Nancy A.
I rarely write reviews by sitting in the restaurant cause i like to give them a chance to change the first impression, but this place started bad and has been getting badder by the minute. 1st its empty at lunch, never a good sign. The girl at the register was playing with her phone and actually told me to give her a mi the while she finish texting or doing whatever she was doing. Now I'm sitting waiting for my food and they are screaming in the kitchen, and not about food! I tried the cheese pizza and the garlic rolls, the latter were delicious. The cheese pizza was ok, nothing to rave about. The prices are pretty good. Would just recommend takeout or delivery
(3)Ed R.
So far im very happy with this place. Probably one of the best pizza places in broward (second only to antonios pizza in east miramar). A good laid back place. I definately recomend this place to all the locals.
(5)Jayme N.
Our family likes to buy pizza at least twice a month, and we are super pleased we tried Coley's Pizza. The pizza tasted great (not too much tomato sauce or too much cheese...just right) and my boys are super picky so this a plus. Service was great. The woman making the pizzas was all smiles in the front which makes the ambiance welcoming. Fun urban vibe and prices are reasonable too so we will definitely be back!
(4)Terry L.
Now dizza izzza Pizza! WOW, I am a fan of this place, it's situated within a plaza on the west side of Pembroke Pines! Immediately upon entering this place, I got the vibe of fun and young (maybe it had something to do with the purple walls or the teenage mutant ninja turtle pictures on the ceiling). This place is rather small but they do have a couple of seats if you wish to sit and enjoy your meal. The food, the pizza was on point, it was hot and they were not cheap in using the toppings. It was not greasy and the dough was baked to perfection. The pizza had good flavor from top to bottom. The toppings I opted for were Pepperoni and Sausage with onions! The Wings were fantastic, they were fried, crispy and tossed into my selection of BBQ sauce. The sauce was extremely flavorful and a little spicy (just the way I like it). I also had the ZEPPOLES (which most places do not have), this desert is simple - dough that is fried and topped with powered sugar - but it is so addicting (like crack) as it's a little chewy and sweet. A great way to end a pizza meal! I did not expect much coming into this place but they have become my go to pizza place! If your in the area I would suggest stopping by and picking up a slice or an entire pie!
(4)Kelsie C.
BEST pizza in south Florida! All their pizzas are GREAT and CREATIVE. Right now my favorite is the spinach Alfredo, but I go through stages. Everything is great and the people and atmosphere is unbeatable. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED
(5)Allie B.
Great local pizza joint. We order from here exclusively. The hot wings are astounding. Whatever Nicole uses in the sauce is amazing. Mondays and Wednesdays are $6.00 cheese pizza days. The staff is always friendly and the atmosphere is cool and artsy.
(5)Dee A.
Ordered 2 slices of cheese pizza and an order for 6 wings and they took 2 hours to deliver. REALLY?! Then when I called them the girl who answered the phone put me on hold rudely. And of course my pizza was freezing. NEVER EVER AGAIN!
(1)Idy U.
OMG, I can't believe that I have been living by this gem for so many years. We ordered a simple pepperoni pizza. The crust, sauce, and toppings were yummy. The only setback was that the pizza was heavier on the oily side. I will be ordering pizza here from now on.
(4)Eddie R.
so, I find this pizza place on yelp. Yelp has never let me down. So I decide to try it, and so should you. It is run by a bunch of really nice girls. The owner, a girl, makes her own sauce, dough, and various other stuff. I tried the pizza. Wow, pretty good. Thin crust, good sauce, good stuff. I've done this 3 times. Next time I asked, meatball or chicken Sangawich. She recommended the chicken. What a really good chicken parm sandwich. I went in today and thought I would try the meatball. Wow, also good. So, my recommendation is this, go/come here. Order something and prepare to enjoy the meal, atmosphere, cost, view (for guys and girls, you'll understand once you come here), Great place to bring the kids, family and friends. This might quickly become one of your favorite places to grab a bite. The door is always open with people coming in for pick up or to eat in. I highly recommend it.
(5)Brian P.
Ordered a $6 pizza yesterday not expecting much and that's exactly what I got! Over cooked dry pizza. Learned my lesson.
(1)Jorge G.
Coleys is the best pizza in Pembroke Pines. Let's start with there service, always friendly and there delivery is exceptionally fast. They will tell you fifty minutes and it will arrive in thirty!! The pizza here is NY style and delicious, sure it's a little greasy but who doesn't like greasy pizza? Great job coleys keep it up.
(5)A C.
This is not the only pizza place in W. Pines. I think she's the owner, she stood the and could not be bothered to greet her customers. Wearing a tank top. Then I ordered my pizza. Said I would be right back. Then I sent my son in they said a few more minutes. So we were right outside waiting, but even though the pizza was ready no one could be bothered to bring it out to us. And I heard them talking about ways to bring in new customers....well try treating the ones in front of you with some customer service!!!!
(1)Santy A.
I tried out Coley's Pizza a few weeks ago with the kids. We had pizza and the honey BBQ wings mixed with the mild sauce. It was delicious! The kids won't eat pizza from anywhere else now and I'm addicted to the wings. We loved the food so much we decided to give them a try for my birthday party. All I can hear at my party was, "where did you get the wings from? Where did you get the chicken parm. from?". Needless to say the food at my party was a huge success thanks to Coley. We had baked ziti, chicken parm. 200 chicken wings honey garlic and honey BBQ, and their awesome garlic bread. If you are looking for great flavor and a hip place to get food from, and good customer service, I suggest you try Coleys Pizza.
(5)Justin G.
My God! How did I not find this place sooner?! By far the best pizza I've had in a very long time. Could arguably be the best pizza secret in S. Florida. Delivery is a little slow (greater than 30 minutes), but it's more than worth the wait! Run. Don't walk.
(5)Fred N.
Follow up on my recent visit, I had placed an order for a pick up at 8:30. I got an automated call minutes later to let me know that the order will be ready in 30 minutes. When I got there a little pass 9pm, I went to the counter to pay for my order. Few minutes later, the cashier told me that my pizza was ready but the wings are not but they should be ready soon. Okay, no problem, I can wait. Maybe I'm too patient but I waited 20 minutes. 20 minutes for just 6 wings?? Okay, let me ask to see where's my order. One of the girls said, oh your order is not yet ready. The wings are ready but the pizza's in the oven now. WTF?!? I thought I was just waiting for the wings?! Apparently, my pizza was probably given away to another order so now I have to wait for ANOTHER 10 minutes for the pizza. This is ridiculous. There was people that came in later than me and they already got their order and left. Smh...there's some serious issues here with how they manage orders. They are lost when it comes to order priorities because they have so many people in the kitchen and cashier. I shouldn't have waited for 30+ minutes considering that I placed the order online for a pick up. I'm not sure if I'll be coming back. I'm a frequent customer and I'm genuinely disappointed.
(1)Jonathan D.
Best Ninja Turtle pizza in town! Came here as a bday surprise and loved it. Friendly staff, fun environment (board game play and cool paintings throughout the ceiling tiles), and the pizza was delish of course! The place is small, more for grab-n-go, but there are some tables to sit in and eat.
(5)Sylvia F.
My son loves this place. We usually order the pizza and wings. My son is very picky so when I find a place he likes......then I like. Staff and owner are very friendly. On week days they have great specials. I always order for pick up. Every time order has been ready when I arrived. The place has a great vibe to it and is clean. Love the fact that the owner is right in front preparing every pizza.
(4)Sara M.
In preparation for the new year, and new year's resolutions, aka: diets, I tried hard to get in all the carbs and calories that I could before setting off on the journey of bland and lifeless cuisine for however long I can stand it. Enter in Coley's for a family pizza night. As I have said before, I do not have an affiliation to any one pizza place and basically go where ever the wind takes me.. or where we have a coupon for. Coley's Pizza had a great deal going on, so naturally they beat out all the many competitors. The deal was for two medium, one-topping pizzas and 6 garlic roles for $20. Actually the coupon we had was expired by 10 days but when we called up and asked if they would honor it, they said sure, no problem. I for one was pretty shocked by this, I am just used to companies being sticklers with their coupons and deals, so Coley's definitely won over some points with this. On top of honoring the expired coupon, they even took off the difference of a topping when we ordered one of the pizzas as just cheese. Who does that? That's awesome! I really appreciate a business that is run with the customer in mind. Great job Coley's! Now on to the food. The pizza was good, it wasn't great, but good. It just missed some pizzaz or that punch of flavor. However, it was not greasy or burnt and the crust was nice. The garlic roles were pretty delicous though. They were really chewy and fluffy and had good garlic flavor without being too overpowering. I would say that their pizza is not my favorite in the area, but definitely a good option. Also, the store was clean and they had an open kitchen so you can see the pizzas being prepared right in front of you, which I always like.
(3)Daddi L.
Amazing Food ! The prices are incredible ! The customer service is awesome ! The pizza is epic perfect blend of cheese with tomato sauce the dough is baked to perfection just enough to satisfy the Saturday afternoon need for good food
(5)Alex P.
I still love this place!!!! They have a BBQ pizza that is to die for. This is my go-to place in Pines for pizza!
(5)Raymond Z.
I came here around 10:30 after a local concert. They closed at 11 but were still happy and willing to seat a friend and I to dine in. For $9, we split a Medium cheese pizza (14" cut into 8 slices). Aside from wishing there was a little more sauce, I have no complaints. Great spot if you're in the area and you'll get good quality for less cost!
(3)Cristina W.
This is the best pizza in south FL!! Everything is fresh and warm, wings are phenomenal and the service can't be beat. I love their cheese pizza, reminds me of how real NY pizza tastes like. Their blue cheese for their wings is also awesome and has actual chunks of blue cheese.
(5)Joseph B.
Coley's is the best NYC style pizza in Pembroke Pines. The pizza is very good. Almost as good as my grandmother's, who is from Italy. I have been coming here for over a year and never received bad service. Nicole the owner is always very friendly and her staff is great. Recommend it highly, if you like New York style pizza.
(5)Erik P.
Amazing Place. Best Pizza. Best Wings. Great atmosphere, cool staff! Coley is always in there working her butt off with a smile on her face. Support her small business! Definitely made a regular out of me. She even knows my voice when I call - and exactly what I'm going to order. Monday is 6$ medium pizza deal (still big!) and Tuesday there are wing deals! Saturdays sometimes they have kid pizza making class for $5.
(5)Max B.
Coley's is our go to for pizza. I know they have plenty of items on the menu and everytime I order I tell myself next time i will try something from the menu. The problem is the pizza is so good I cant think of ordering anything else. I have ordered the wings, they are good but still cant beat the pizza. Good service, they are fast, and always get my order right. What more can you ask for.
(4)Nikki C.
Coleys Pizza is by far the best ever! It's comparable to the great pizza spots I been to in NYC. Take out is very quick. I order delivery and it's here so fast! I met coley once and she is very nice, along with the rest of the staff.
(5)Andres O.
The pizza was okay. Very greasy and no napkins to be found anywhere. The service was mediocre and the place was pretty tight in space. It made it kind of uncomfortable. I won't be going back soon especially since pizza places are abundant in this part of Pembroke Pines
(3)Michelle G.
Coley's is the best pizza joint on this side of town. The garlic bread points are god send (much better than the rolls) and the pies are 100% wow! Love the powdered zeppoli with condensed milk dipper! Way to go, Coley's -- you never let us down!
(4)Jenny Q. V.
Uh... I've had better. Prices are pretty good but food is BLAH. I ordered barbq wings and they were pretty boring and tasteless. Ordered the spaghetti and meatballs and got spaghetti and meat sauce more sauce then meat. It's close to home but I will probably never order from there again. I rather go to doughboys right across from Flannigans on pines blvd
(2)Luis L.
Great place for pizza. All the varieties of pies i have had are good. I recommend to all. Plus, service is always great and friendly.
(4)Ronald S.
The best pizza in Pembroke Pines West. If you go there and order your pizza will take a some good minutes but it is a good opportunity to see that everything are carefully made and fresh.
(5)Elizabeth A.
Love the way they make the pizza, wings and the service is excellent. I recommend this place to anyone!!!
(5)Milden D.
They are the best pizza in Pembroke Pines hand off! A relocated NY native I know my pizzas and this the closest to NY style pizza I've had. Their wings and homemade sauce yum! Also tried their signature wing it pizza and it was amazing (you can choose the wing sauce)
(5)Arlette S.
Really good pizza was our first time to this place and will go back again I love the pizza I ate 4 slices I had to stop myself because I was about to eat the entire pie That's how good the pizza was !!!!good job guys !!!
(5)Dee D.
I ordered delivery, online, at 1:15pm. I received a call from an automated system saying it would be 45 minutes plus delivery time. At 2:30 I called and the woman on the phone was very dismissive and told me the driver left over 15 minutes ago. The driver arrived shortly thereafter. Dropped off our appetizers (wings and an appetizer sampler) and tells us he grabbed the wrong pizzas and would be right back with the correct order. We were grateful he left something. I open the appetizer platter and realize they did not provide my onion rings that I ordered. I called back and the same woman wouldn't let me get a word in, and just went on to explain that the food should be there any minute. I waited for her to stop talking then explained the reason for my call. She then says "well since he has to go back I will send onion rings", so if not you wouldn't have sent them? No apology or anything for the mistakes. The driver arrived at around 3:15 with our new pizza and onion rings. The pizza was warm at best, borderline cold. He did apologize for all the confusion, though there was no attempt at customer service recovery. I expected a bit more after waiting for 2 hours for pizza.
(2)Aramis F.
We ordered pizza from here for the first time, we ordered this thing that comes with a small container of condensed milk it's like a dessert. The guy who packed the pizza put the condensed milk container in the pizza box, needless to say it melted and spread the condensed milk under the pizza. We called and they said that they would send another pizza which they did but they wanted the messed up pizza back when they guy arrived he said we Should not have eaten any of the pizza which we had a few slices that where not damaged. The way this restaurant handled this sucked. I would have let the customer keep the messed up pizza due to the inconvenience so that at least they could have a few slices while the problem is corrected. I will definitely not order from there again. It was our first time and now it will be the last. You want better pizza try Marcos pizza, at least I have never had any issues like this. What crap Customer service and the pizza is not all that.
(1)Yes B.
This had been our go to pizza place. Staff is super friendly, the wings are awesome and the pizza is always a hit at our house. They offered a pizza making class a while back and we had our boys (7 and 9) make pizza with Nicole. They had a blast! Lately the pizza has not been as good as it used to so Im giving it 3stars.
(3)Nicole C.
Delicious food! Easily the best pizza in Pembroke Pines. The environment is fun and enjoyable and the service is always great. Last night we actually decided to try something other than our regular half cheese/half pepperoni and had buffalo chicken Philly cheesesteaks. Yum. They were to die for. I definitely recommend that to anyone who isn't in the mood for pizza.
(5)Bardiya A.
One of the best pizza that I have eaten in the U.S. I liked the NY pizza with my topping selection which was black olives, sausage, pepperoni, and onion. The smokehouse pizza was kind of sweet, but It was delicious. I picked up the pizzas, so I didn't have any problem with delivery stuffs. The price was good. The problems are that they did not have enough seats, and the staffs were not very friendly. I have to mention it again, I really liked the pizza taste.
(4)A M.
So, I just moved to Florida and I am looking for a good pizza place. The reviews made this place sound like the most amazing pizza ever. Ok, so maybe I ordered on a off night. I ordered The Smokehouse pizza, a pepperoni stromboli, chicken wings and their zeppoli donuts. All of the dough was chewy, like really chewy. Not sure if it was old dough or what. The chicken wings half honey garlic / dali lama, they were fresh but had no flavor, we had to put BBQ sauce on them. The stromboli was OK, still chewy. The zeppoli donuts were chewy as well.The food was edible because I was hungry. Not sure if I will give this place another shot. This was literally the chewiest pizza I have ever eaten. Not cool
(2)Selene T.
This place is great. The food is fresh and awesome! The owner, Nicole, is very nice and she makes everything in-house. She'll be tossing pizzas and talking to you at the same time. We have eaten here 3 times, once on a a week night, once on a weekend night and the third time on a weekday afternoon. They are always busy! A sign of good food. We've had the subs.... The eggplant parm ($6) 8"sub was amazing, the bread is nice and warm, soft on the inside and toasty on the outside. My husband had the philly cheesesteak ($7.50) and they use great tasting meat, lots of onions, peppers, and cheese. Now for the bonus, they have Curly Fries (only $1 more added as a side for the subs)!!! we always order a side of their homemade medium wing sauce. We like spicy food, but the medium here is the Hot anywhere else. So be careful. The pizza dough is amazing, the sauce is so yummy, it has Parmesan cheese in it. Now to the mozzarella.... Good and fresh cheese will stretch and it will not be chewy, here Coley's hits a home run, so flavorful. We had The Edgy Veggie pie ($15 for the 14") and it had tons of Fresh vegetables, and this pizza looked way bigger than 14 inches. (I put a photo up, check it out) Today we tried their pasta. The spaghetti and tomato sauce ($7). All their pasta dishes come with 2 amazingly airy garlic rolls and a side salad. What a great deal. I took 1 star off because each time we've come the tables have been dirty, they need to pay more attention to that. They do come and clean them when you ask :) And because the pasta was a little over cooked (in my opinion) and the sauce was lacking flavor. We had to add lots of pepper flakes, salt, garlic, oregano and Parmesan cheese to make it taste better. We did tell Nicole about it and she said that she'll be happy to add more flavor to ours if we remind her when we're ordering :) NOW THAT'S SERVICE!!! Check out their menu, I put pictures up.
(4)Jay F.
Coley rocks! She makes the best pizza in town. Affordable and really customer service oriented.
(5)Sharyna B.
Amazing pizza place. Me and my guys order from here all the time at work. A+ just wish they gave us a military discount. Lol.
(5)Veljne A.
This place will redefine your love for pizza. You'll never order a pie from another place once you've had a slice at this neighborhood friendly joint. Stop on in and pick up a pie, a Coley's T-shirt, and some stickers while you're at it.
(5)Suhay R.
I love coming here to get pizza. The staff is friendly and prompt. I have never had any issues here. The manager and staff are ALWAYS ready to assist.
(4)Raquel E.
Best pizza in West Pines!!! Great service and the pizza is so yummy. It's not all crust and bread, it's actually thin delicious pizza.
(5)Mary Ann C.
We ordered a few pizzas to go from here and were happy with the results. I've heard that they have the recipe from Baci's Pizza which is now gone. They don't have a brick oven but their pizza is nice and crispy with lots of cheese. It was a hit with the kids, especially the extra large size the offer. They have pizza specials on Tuesdays. The staff were very friendly and helpful in ordering and picking up. Now I'm getting hungry. This week I'm ordering Coley's!
(4)Shanna L.
Great NY style pizza! The hot wings are crispy and the sauce is not just your typical sauce, it's flavorful and delicious. We have had the food delivered and have often picked it up ourselves and the food has always been hot and our orders have been correct. Love supporting small business rather than a chain and trust me, This place is definitely worth it!
(5)Karen C.
Don't know what happened here, whether it was bad night or what cause there are some good reviews but we got delivery a few of nights ago and will never order from them again. Pizza soggy and greasy. Margherita pizza had a funny "off" taste to it that got even worse with leftovers next day. We ended up throwing away all but 2-1/4 slices of Margherita, over half of the meatball pizza and a couple of slices of the pepperoni. I will say food was delivered well before promised time (and that's the only reason they got 2 stars) and that was a plus but can't afford to waste money by throwing food away.
(2)Bryan K.
This place is a nice local pizza dive place...typical New York dirty style restaurant. Front door is always open I guess they have no clue it's a health code violation..If you watch no one ever washes there hands even after touching money ...then they cut a pizza and touch it to make it fit in boxes that they only make when the pizza comes out... ..There is always a wait on Friday and Saturday and everyone seems to run around like a chicken with there head cut off..last time we got a salad there we had hair as a topping in it... But with that said it is probably the best pizza west of 75..
(3)Timothy M.
My go to pizza joint. So much better than the chains. The only pizza I'd rather have is up at home in Chicago. I've recommended Coley's to friends and they all love the place.
(5)Charles G.
Just ordered 2 pizzas with garlic rolls for delivery. Reasonable delivery time and the pizzas were delicious. Found a new pizza place. No more Pizza Hut or papa johns. Love fresh made crust.
(5)Nikki C.
I recently relocated back to Pembroke pines and was in search of a good pizza place. So I sent my hubby to do some research and he came across Coleys pizza so we decided to give Coleys a try , I must say I am so happy we did :) The food is very good The pizza was delicious as well as the wings & fries. You should definitely give them a try !!! You wont be disappointed!
(4)